Richtlinien

Streitbeilegungsrichtlinie

Die INDEX-Streitbeilegungsrichtlinie (IDRP): Anwendungsbereich, Verfahren, Fristen, unabhängiges Gremium, Abhilfemaßnahmen und Verhältnis zu den Gerichten.

Ausgabe 1.0Veröffentlicht am 21. November 202617 Min. LesezeitLire en français
Dieses Dokument wird auf Französisch und Englisch veröffentlicht. Die englische Fassung ist die Referenzfassung. Nachstehend wird die englische Fassung wiedergegeben.

01Purpose and principles

The INDEX Dispute Resolution Policy (“IDRP”) sets out how disputes about the content of the INDEX register are raised, examined and decided. It applies to every record, certificate and attestation in the register of INDEX.FILM — International AI Audiovisual Asset Registry, operated by the International AI Audiovisual Asset Index Standards Alliance, “the Alliance”.

INDEX records registration facts and verification scope, supporting the recognition of rights worldwide. The IDRP rests on the following principles:

  1. The Registry does not decide who owns rights in a work. Ownership, authorship, infringement and damages are matters for courts and other competent authorities.
  2. An independent panel decides what the register should record about a work, and with what flags, on the evidence presented by the parties.
  3. The Registry implements final court decisions and arbitral awards that concern a record, as they apply to the register.
  4. The procedure is written, fast and proportionate. Decisions are reasoned and published, with personal data anonymised.
  5. The IDRP does not prevent anyone from going to court before, during or after the proceedings.

Accredited registrars and issuers are bound by the IDRP under their programme agreements. Registrants accept it through their agreement with their registrar, and complainants by filing a complaint.

02Definitions

Registry Office
The body of the Alliance that operates the register. Under the IDRP it receives complaints, carries out the administrative review, communicates with the parties, applies interim measures and implements decisions. It does not decide the merits.
Record
The public entry for one work in the register, identified by its INDEX ID, with all its versions, fields, flags, attestations and documents.
Registrant
The party that declared the work through a registrar and is answerable for the declaration. The Registry stores it as an opaque reference supplied by the registrar.
Rights holder
The person or organisation named in the record as holding rights in the work, as declared by the registrant or verified by an issuer.
Sponsoring registrar
The accredited registrar through which the record is currently registered.
Issuer
Any party that signs an attestation about a work: the Registry, accredited registrars, accredited law firms and festivals.
Attestation
A signed statement about a work made by an issuer, in particular a VERIFIED scope, a Rights Clearance Schedule (CLEARED) or an honour.
Complainant
The person or organisation that files a complaint.
Respondent
The registrant of the record concerned or, for a complaint about an attestation, the issuer that signed it. A complaint may name both.
Dispute Resolution Panel
The published list of independent panellists appointed by the Governing Council for three-year terms.
Panel
The one or three panellists appointed from the Dispute Resolution Panel to decide a complaint.
Disputed flag
The public status “disputed” shown on a record while a complaint is pending, displayed on the verification page as “Under review”.
Day, business day
A day is a calendar day. A business day is any day other than a Saturday, a Sunday or a public holiday in Belgium. Time limits are computed in Brussels time, begin on the day after the event that triggers them and end at the close of their last day.

03Scope and exclusions

A complaint may be filed on one or more of the following grounds. For each ground, the table states what the complainant must show.

GroundThe complainant must show
1. Conflicting claims to be the rights holder of a registered workThat it claims to hold the rights recorded for the work, and that on the evidence its claim is better supported than the rights-holder statement in the record.
2. Registration without authority (unauthorised registration)That it holds or represents rights in the work, or is the person whose authority the registration required, and that the registrant lacked authority to register the work as recorded when the registration was made.
3. Materially false or misleading record data, including AI disclosure and real-person likenessThat record fields are false or misleading; that the inaccuracy is material, meaning it could affect how a reasonable verifier understands the work, its origin, its rights position or its use of AI; and that it has a legitimate interest in the correction.
4. Disputes about a transfer between registrarsThat sponsorship was transferred without the authority of the rights holder or registrant, without a valid transfer code or otherwise in breach of the INDEX Standard, or that a valid transfer request was refused or obstructed without good reason.
5. Complaints about an issuer’s attestation (VERIFIED scope, CLEARED schedule, honour)That the attestation is materially inaccurate, was issued outside the issuer’s accredited scope, or lacks the basis it states.

Outside the scope

  • Determining the ownership of copyright or other rights with effect against third parties, and awarding damages, costs or other monetary relief. These are matters for courts and other competent authorities.
  • Fee disputes between a registrar and its client, which go to the registrar’s own procedure.
  • Accreditation, membership and compliance matters, which follow the programme agreements and the procedures of the Accreditation and Compliance Committee.
  • Requests concerning personal data, which are handled under the Privacy Notice.

04Who may file

Any natural or legal person with a legitimate interest in the content of a record may file a complaint, in particular:

  • a person or organisation that claims to hold, or to be authorised to exercise, rights in the registered work;
  • a person whose likeness or voice is used or represented in the work, as regards the AI disclosure and real-person likeness statements;
  • the registrant or rights holder of the record, and an accredited registrar involved in a transfer, as regards a transfer dispute;
  • any person directly affected by an attestation, as regards that attestation.

A complainant may act through a representative with written authority. Several complainants with a common interest may file a single complaint.

05The complaint

A complaint is filed by email to legal@index.film, with the subject line “IDRP complaint” followed by the INDEX ID concerned. It is written in English or French and contains:

  1. the name, address and email of the complainant and of any representative, with the representative’s written authority; for an organisation, its legal form and registration details;
  2. the INDEX ID of each record and the number of each certificate or attestation concerned; one complaint may cover several records relating to the same work or registered by the same registrant;
  3. the respondent: the registrant, identified by the INDEX ID, and, for a complaint about an attestation, the issuer;
  4. the grounds relied on, with the facts and arguments for each;
  5. the remedies requested, chosen from the remedies of the IDRP;
  6. whether a panel of three panellists is requested;
  7. any other legal proceedings concerning the work or the record, with copies of any decisions;
  8. an index of the evidence, each document attached and numbered as an annex;
  9. the declaration below, signed by the complainant or its representative.

Evidence

Evidence is attached as copies in PDF or another common format. Documents in other languages are accompanied by a translation into the language of the proceedings, unless the panel dispenses with it. The panel may request originals or certified copies. Files relevant for their content, such as cuts of a work, are identified by their SHA-256 fingerprint and made available to the panel on request.

Declaration

The complainant declares that the complaint is complete and accurate to the best of its knowledge and is not filed for an improper purpose; that it accepts publication of the decision with personal data anonymised; and that the Alliance, the Registry Office and the panellists are liable in connection with the proceedings only for wilful misconduct or gross negligence, to the extent permitted by law.

Fees

The complaint is subject to the filing fee and, where three panellists are requested, the additional panel fee, as set out in the current fee schedule. Fees are invoiced by billing@index.film. A complaint is not processed until the fees are paid, and is deemed withdrawn if they are not paid within the period stated on the invoice.

06Administrative review

Within 5 business days of receiving the complaint, the Registry Office checks that it falls within the scope of the IDRP, that the required information, evidence index and declaration are present, and that the records, certificates and attestations concerned exist. This review does not assess the merits.

Deficiencies are notified to the complainant and may be corrected within 5 business days. A complaint that is not corrected in time, or falls manifestly outside the scope, is closed with reasons, without prejudice to a new complaint.

The proceedings commence on the date on which the Registry Office confirms that the complaint is compliant and the fees have been paid (the “commencement date”).

07Interim measures

If the complaint appears well-founded on its face, the Registry Office flags the record publicly as “disputed” within 2 business days of the commencement date. The record page and the verification page then show that a rights matter is under review; existing certificates continue to verify with that indication.

The Registry Office may also put on hold the issuance of new certificates for the record until the proceedings end.

Interim measures express no view on the merits. They end when the complaint is closed, withdrawn, settled or dismissed, or when the decision has been implemented; where court proceedings are shown under the implementation rules, the record stays flagged until the court decides. The respondent may ask for an interim measure to be reviewed, giving reasons; the Registry Office decides promptly or, once appointed, the panel decides.

08Notification and communications

Once the proceedings have commenced, the Registry Office notifies the complaint and its annexes to the respondent:

  • to the registrant through the sponsoring registrar, since the Registry holds only an opaque registrant reference. The registrar forwards the complaint without delay and confirms forwarding to the Registry Office;
  • to the issuer directly, at the address given in its programme agreement.

The date of notification is the date of the registrar’s confirmation or, for an issuer, the date of sending. If the registrar cannot reach the registrant, it reports the steps taken; the proceedings then continue and the registrant is treated as notified.

All communications are made by email through legal@index.film, which copies them to the other parties. No party may communicate with a panellist except through the Registry Office. A communication is deemed received on the day it is sent, unless delivery fails.

09The response

The respondent has 20 days from the date of notification to submit a response to legal@index.film, in English or French. The response:

  1. identifies the respondent and any representative; a registrant may identify itself through its registrar, which confirms its identity to the Registry Office;
  2. replies specifically to each ground and statement in the complaint;
  3. sets out the facts and documents relied on, in particular authority to register the work, chain of title, licences and consents, or the basis of the attestation;
  4. states whether three panellists are requested, if the complainant has not done so;
  5. mentions any other legal proceedings concerning the work or the record;
  6. attaches and numbers its evidence, and contains the same declaration as the complaint.

In exceptional cases, at the respondent’s reasoned request or by agreement of the parties, the Registry Office may extend the response period once.

If no response is received, the panel decides on the complaint and the evidence. A default is not in itself a reason to grant the complaint: each element of the ground must still be shown.

10Appointment of the panel

The panel is appointed within 5 business days of receipt of the response or of the end of the response period.

Composition

  • A complaint is decided by one panellist, unless the complainant or the respondent requests three. The fee for a three-member panel is as set out in the current fee schedule.
  • The Registry Office appoints panellists from the published list of the Dispute Resolution Panel, having regard to the language of the proceedings, the subject matter, availability and conflicts.
  • For a three-member panel, each party may indicate up to three panellists from the list. The Registry Office appoints one from each party’s indications where possible, and a third, who presides.
  • Registry staff and registrars are never panellists.

Independence and impartiality

Each panellist must be impartial and independent of the parties, the sponsoring registrar and the issuer concerned. Before accepting an appointment, each panellist signs a declaration of independence and impartiality and discloses any circumstance likely to give rise to justifiable doubts, such as a professional relationship with a party or a personal interest in the outcome. The duty of disclosure continues throughout the proceedings.

Challenges

A party may challenge a panellist by a reasoned request to legal@index.film, made promptly after learning of the grounds and before the decision. The Registry Office decides after hearing the panellist and the other party; its decision is final for the proceedings. A panellist who is successfully challenged, withdraws or cannot act is replaced in the same way, and the time limit for the decision runs again.

11Conduct of the proceedings

  • The proceedings are in writing. The panel conducts them as it considers appropriate, treating the parties equally and giving each a fair opportunity to present its case.
  • The language of the proceedings is English or French, as chosen in the complaint, or another language agreed by the parties. The panel may decide otherwise, having regard in particular to the languages the respondent understands.
  • Supplementary submissions are admitted only at the panel’s discretion. The panel may request further statements or documents from the parties, the sponsoring registrar or the issuer, within a time limit it sets.
  • There are no hearings, unless the panel decides in an exceptional case that one is necessary; it is then held by video conference.
  • The panel may consolidate complaints concerning the same record or work, draw appropriate inferences from a party’s failure to comply with a time limit or request and, in exceptional circumstances, extend a time limit, giving reasons.
  • Submissions are confidential to the parties, the panel, the Registry Office and, as needed for implementation, the sponsoring registrar and the issuer, subject to publication of the decision.

12Standard of proof and evidence

The complainant must show each element of the ground relied on, on the balance of probabilities. Where the complainant makes a prima facie case that the registrant lacked authority, the respondent must produce evidence of its authority. The panel decides on the evidence presented and does not conduct its own investigation, but may take account of the public register.

The panel determines the admissibility, relevance and weight of the evidence. It considers in particular:

  • registration data and record history: versions, hash chain, the source of each field (declared or verified) and RFC 3161 time-stamps;
  • signed attestations and credentials, with their issuers, scopes, bases and status;
  • contracts: production, commissioning, employment, assignment and licence agreements and other chain-of-title documents;
  • consents, in particular to the use of a real person’s likeness or voice, and the terms of use of the AI tools used;
  • time-stamps, content fingerprints and other technical evidence that a file existed at a given time;
  • decisions of courts, arbitral tribunals and other competent authorities, and entries in official registers.

The existence of an INDEX record, or the fact that a work was registered first, does not in itself show that the registrant holds rights in the work. The register shows who declared what and when, and what was verified, by whom and on what basis.

13The decision

The panel issues a reasoned decision in writing within 14 days of its appointment. A three-member panel decides by majority; a dissenting opinion may be attached.

The decision states the parties and records concerned, the grounds and remedies requested, a summary of the submissions, the findings on each element, the remedies ordered, any declaration of abuse of procedure, the date and the name of each panellist.

The decision determines only what the register should record and with what flags. It does not determine ownership of rights with effect against third parties and does not award damages or costs. The Registry Office notifies it without delay to the parties, the sponsoring registrar and, where relevant, the issuer.

14Remedies

The panel may order one or more of the following remedies, and no others:

  1. correct record fields (new version);
  2. replace the rights holder or registrant reference;
  3. transfer sponsorship to another registrar;
  4. suspend or revoke an attestation;
  5. revoke a certificate, which then verifies as revoked;
  6. revoke the record; the INDEX ID is never reused, and the record remains publicly resolvable with its revoked status;
  7. dismiss the complaint and remove the flag.

Remedies other than dismissal are ordered only if requested, and only as far as needed for the register to reflect the panel’s findings. Where a reference is replaced or sponsorship transferred, the complainant designates the accredited registrar that will sponsor the record and supply the new registrant reference.

15Implementation and court proceedings

The Registry Office implements the decision 10 business days after its notification, unless within that period a party shows that it has started court proceedings in a competent jurisdiction concerning the subject matter of the decision, by sending to legal@index.film a copy of the document starting the proceedings with evidence of its filing.

In that case the record stays flagged until the court decides. The Registry Office then implements the final court decision as it applies to the register; or the panel’s decision, if the court proceedings are withdrawn or discontinued; or a settlement notified jointly by the parties.

A competent jurisdiction is a court with jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter under the applicable law, including the courts of the place where the respondent or the sponsoring registrar is established. Arbitration under an agreement binding on the parties has the same effect.

Implementation is recorded in the history of the record with a reference to the decision. A final court decision or arbitral award prevails over a panel decision.

16Settlement and withdrawal

  • The parties may settle at any time. At their joint request, the Registry Office suspends the proceedings for the period requested; they resume at the request of either party.
  • A settlement is notified jointly to legal@index.film, stating any changes to the register, which are carried out if consistent with the INDEX Standard. The proceedings are then terminated.
  • The complainant may withdraw the complaint before the decision. A complaint withdrawn after the response may not be refiled on the same facts and grounds without the respondent’s consent.
  • On termination or withdrawal, the interim measures end and the flag is removed, unless another complaint about the record is pending.
  • Any refund of fees follows the current fee schedule.

17Abuse of procedure

If the panel finds that a complaint was filed in bad faith, it declares it an abuse of procedure. Bad faith includes in particular:

  • filing mainly to harass the respondent, to use the disputed flag as leverage, or to disrupt the distribution, exhibition or sale of a work;
  • filing while knowing that the registrant had authority or that the record is accurate;
  • submitting forged, altered or knowingly misleading evidence;
  • repeating a decided complaint without new evidence.

The declaration is published with the decision. The Registry Office may then require later complaints by the same complainant to be examined by a panel before any interim measure is applied. Bad faith or forged evidence by an accredited registrar, issuer or member is referred to the Accreditation and Compliance Committee, and forged evidence may be reported to the competent authorities.

18Publication of decisions

Decisions are published on index.film in the language of the proceedings and referenced in the history of the record. Personal data is anonymised: information identifying natural persons is removed or replaced by neutral designations. Organisations may be named.

On a reasoned request, the panel may order confidential business information to be redacted. The INDEX ID, grounds, findings and remedies are always published. Settlement terms and withdrawn complaints are not published; the record history shows only that proceedings were opened and how they ended.

19Relationship with courts and other proceedings

  • The IDRP does not prevent anyone from going to court, or to arbitration where agreed, before, during or after the proceedings. A panel decision does not bind any court.
  • The parties inform the Registry Office without delay of court or arbitration proceedings on the same subject matter. The panel may then suspend or terminate the proceedings, or continue to a decision.
  • The Registry implements final court decisions and arbitral awards concerning a record on receipt at legal@index.film of a copy, evidence that it is final and, if needed, a translation into English or French. It may require a certified copy.
  • The Alliance, the Registry Office and the panellists are not parties to the dispute. Panellists do not act as witnesses or experts in later proceedings about a case they decided.

20Obligations of registrars and issuers

Accredited registrars and issuers accept the IDRP under their programme agreements.

Registrars

  • Include in their registrant agreements a provision by which the registrant accepts the IDRP.
  • Forward complaints and communications to the registrant without delay, and confirm forwarding.
  • From the commencement date until the decision is implemented or the court decides, keep the record as it stands: no transfer of sponsorship, no change to the fields in dispute and no request for a new certificate, except as the Registry Office or the panel directs.
  • Provide the panel on request with the registration data and evidence they hold, within the limits of applicable law.
  • Carry out decisions, final court decisions and settlements as the Registry Office instructs, and make no attempt to influence the outcome of proceedings.

Issuers

  • Answer complaints about their attestations, and produce to the panel the scope, method and evidence references of the attestation.
  • Keep the evidence on which each attestation is based available for the proceedings.
  • Issue no new attestation on the matter in dispute while the record is flagged, except as the panel directs.
  • Suspend, revoke or correct an attestation as the decision requires.

A failure to meet these obligations is a compliance matter under the programme agreement and is referred to the Accreditation and Compliance Committee.

21Time limits

StepTime limitRuns from
Administrative review5 business daysReceipt of the complaint
Correction of a deficient complaint5 business daysNotice of the deficiencies
Disputed flag, if the complaint appears well-founded on its face2 business daysCommencement date
Notification to the respondentWithout delayCommencement date
Response20 daysDate of notification
Appointment of the panel5 business daysReceipt of the response, or end of the response period
Decision14 daysAppointment of the panel
Implementation10 business daysNotification of the decision, unless court proceedings are shown to have started

22Amendments and entry into force

  • The IDRP is maintained by the Standards Committee. Proposed amendments are published for public comment for at least 30 days, after consultation of the Registrar Council and the Dispute Resolution Panel, and are approved by the Governing Council.
  • Amendments apply to complaints filed after their entry into force. Pending proceedings continue under the edition in force at their commencement date.
  • This is Edition 1.0 of the IDRP, published on 21 November 2026, and it enters into force on that date.
  • The IDRP is published in English and French. The English edition is the reference edition and prevails where the editions differ.
Bewerbungen

Treten Sie dem weltweiten Registernetzwerk bei.

Streitbeilegungsrichtlinie · INDEX.FILM