Libros blancos

Hechos registrales y reconocimiento de derechos

Cómo abordan las principales jurisdicciones las obras creadas con asistencia de IA y cómo los hechos registrales y el alcance de la verificación contribuyen al reconocimiento de los derechos.

Edición 1.0Publicado el 21 de noviembre de 2026Lectura de 18 minLire en français
Este documento se publica en francés y en inglés. La edición en inglés es la edición de referencia. El texto que figura a continuación corresponde a la edición en inglés.

01Executive summary

When a film, a series or a character has been made partly with AI tools, who holds rights in it, and how can anyone show it? Every producer, distributor, festival, financier and insurer working with AI audiovisual works meets this question. This paper surveys how selected legal systems approach it and explains what a registry can, and cannot, contribute to the answer.

  1. In the countries party to the Berne Convention, copyright does not depend on registration. Registers do not create rights; they serve evidence, notice and trust.
  2. Across the jurisdictions reviewed, copyright is tied to human creative contribution. Material produced by an AI system without it is generally not protected as such, while human creative choices — in the script, the direction, the selection and arrangement of material, the editing — can be. Where the line falls is decided case by case, and the law is still developing.
  3. Because rights turn on facts — who did what, when, with which tools, under which licences and consents — evidence matters even more for AI works than for conventionally produced ones. Attributable, time-stamped and versioned statements make those facts easier for courts, insurers and buyers to assess.
  4. INDEX.FILM records registration facts and verification scope, supporting the recognition of rights worldwide. It separates what a registrant declares from what an accredited issuer has verified, and time-stamps every version of a record. It does not decide, grant or certify rights: courts and competent authorities do.

02Why the question matters for AI audiovisual works

An audiovisual work is layered: screenplay, storyboards, generated and filmed images, synthetic and recorded voices, music, sound, editing and grading, each with its own contributors and legal position. AI tools can intervene at any layer. The questions they raise fall into four groups.

Human creative contribution

Copyright protects expression that results from human creative choices. Where part of a work is produced by an AI system, the question is whether, and to what extent, a person made the choices that give the work its expressive form. The answer may differ between layers of the same film: a human-written script and a human-directed edit may be protected even where individual generated shots are not.

Chain of title

Distributors, broadcasters, sales agents and insurers ask for a chain of title: the documented agreements by which rights pass from the people who created a work to the party that licenses it. In AI productions the chain has additional links — tool terms of service, licences for models, datasets or reference material, and agreements with prompt designers, technical artists and studios. A gap in any link makes a work harder to sell, finance or insure.

Licensed inputs

AI systems are built and steered with inputs: training data, reference images, voice samples, style material, the producer’s own earlier work. Whether those inputs were used lawfully is separate from whether the output is protected, and the rules, including exceptions for text and data mining, vary by country. A producer cannot always know how a third-party model was trained, but can document which tools and which licensed or owned inputs were used.

Likeness and performers

AI can reproduce or simulate a person’s face, body and voice. Depending on the country, these are protected through personality or image rights, data protection law, rights of publicity, contract and performers’ rights — independently of copyright. A work may be fully protected by copyright and still infringe the rights of a person whose likeness it uses without consent. Records of consent are therefore part of the rights position of the work.

03The international baseline

The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works (1886, as revised at Paris in 1971) is the common foundation of copyright for the great majority of states, and cinematographic works are among the works it protects. Its substantive rules are also incorporated, with limited exceptions, into the World Trade Organization’s Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS, 1994).

Protection without formalities

Under Article 5(2) of the Convention, the enjoyment and exercise of the rights it guarantees are not subject to any formality. Copyright in Berne countries therefore arises when a qualifying work is created, without registration, deposit or notice. Each country remains free to regulate protection of works originating in it, and some attach procedural consequences to registration, as the United States does. But registration is not a condition of copyright in Berne countries.

Attribution as evidence

The Convention itself gives weight to attribution. Under Article 15, the person whose name appears on a work in the usual manner is, in the absence of proof to the contrary, regarded as its author for the purpose of infringement proceedings. Credits and other statements of authorship matter — as a starting point, open to proof to the contrary.

What registers are for

Because rights do not depend on registration, registers in Berne countries serve other functions. They provide evidence: a dated statement of who claimed what, and on what basis. They give notice: anyone can find who claims a work. They support trust: buyers, platforms and festivals can rely on consistent, identified information. The legal weight of an entry depends on national law and on the register: some public registers carry presumptions under national law; others carry the weight a court or counterparty gives them as evidence.

The Convention does not expressly define “author” and does not address works produced with AI. Whether a human author is required, and how much human contribution is enough, is left to national law and courts.

04Jurisdiction overviews

The overviews that follow summarise publicly known developments up to mid-2026 in selected jurisdictions relevant to the international audiovisual market. They are deliberately brief, cite sources by name and year, and describe the direction of the law rather than every nuance. Several sources are guidance documents or first-instance decisions. Nothing here should be relied on without checking the current position locally.

JurisdictionHuman authorship requirementNotable sourceStatus note
United StatesYes. Material generated by AI without human authorship is not registrable; human selection, arrangement and modification can be.US Copyright Office registration guidance (2023); Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 2: Copyrightability (2025); Thaler v. Perlmutter (D.C. Circuit, 2025)Office guidance and an appellate decision; case-by-case assessment
European UnionGenerally understood to require human creative choices (the author’s own intellectual creation).CJEU, Infopaq, C-5/08 (2009) and later case law; AI Act, Regulation (EU) 2024/1689Application to AI-assisted works still to be clarified; AI Act transparency rules concern disclosure, not copyright
United KingdomHuman authorship is the norm; special provision for computer-generated works.Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, section 9(3); government consultation on copyright and AI (2024–2025)Section 9(3) under review; check the current position
ChinaCopyright recognised where the user’s intellectual input was found sufficient.Beijing Internet Court, Li v. Liu (2023)First-instance, fact-specific decision; not a settled national rule
JapanDepends on human creative contribution.Agency for Cultural Affairs, General Understanding on AI and Copyright (2024)Administrative guidance; courts decide
Republic of KoreaMaterial generated by AI alone is not registrable; human creative contributions can be.Government guide on generative AI and copyright (2023)Government guidance
Thailand, Belgium, France and other Berne countriesHuman author generally presupposed.National copyright law; Berne ConventionCheck for specific local guidance

05United States

US copyright law protects original works of authorship, and the US Copyright Office and the courts have long treated human authorship as a requirement. Registration is not a condition of copyright, but it has procedural consequences: for United States works it is generally required before an infringement action can be brought, and timely registration affects the remedies available.

Registration guidance (2023)

In March 2023 the Office published registration guidance for works containing material generated by AI. Applicants must disclose the inclusion of AI-generated material, briefly describe the human author’s contribution, and exclude — disclaim — AI-generated material that is more than de minimis. A work can be registered for its human-authored elements, which may include the creative selection, coordination or arrangement of AI-generated material and human modifications of it.

Copyrightability report (2025)

In January 2025 the Office published Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 2: Copyrightability. It confirms the human authorship requirement and calls for case-by-case analysis. Among its conclusions: using AI to assist human creativity, rather than to stand in for it, does not affect protection of the human contribution; prompts alone, given the technology generally available at the time, do not give the user enough control to be the author of the output; and human expressive inputs perceptible in the output, as well as creative selection, arrangement and modification of AI-generated material, can be protected.

Thaler v. Perlmutter (2025)

In March 2025 the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upheld the Office’s refusal to register a work that the applicant stated had been generated autonomously by an AI system, with no human author claimed. The court held that the Copyright Act requires a work to be authored in the first instance by a human being. The case did not concern a person using AI as a tool, and does not mark where that line lies.

For the US market, the rights position of an AI audiovisual work must therefore be described element by element. An INDEX record does not replace registration with the Office.

06European Union

EU copyright is partly harmonised and is interpreted by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). In Infopaq International (C-5/08, 2009), the Court held that protection extends to subject matter that is original in the sense of being its author’s own intellectual creation. Later judgments have described originality in terms of free and creative choices reflecting the author’s personality. This standard is generally understood to require human creative choices; how it applies to particular forms of AI-assisted creation remains to be clarified.

The AI Act

Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, the Artificial Intelligence Act, is not a copyright law. Its transparency obligations in Article 50, applicable from 2 August 2026 under the Regulation as adopted, concern disclosure. Subject to limited exceptions, providers of AI systems generating synthetic audio, image, video or text must ensure that outputs are marked in a machine-readable format and detectable as artificially generated or manipulated; deployers who generate or manipulate image, audio or video content constituting a deep fake must disclose it. For evidently artistic, creative, satirical or fictional works, that disclosure is limited to an appropriate manner that does not hamper the display or enjoyment of the work. Readers should check whether later amendments affect timing or scope.

The Act also requires providers of general-purpose AI models to maintain a policy to comply with Union copyright law and to publish a summary of the content used for training. These obligations concern model providers, not the authorship of individual works.

Text and data mining

Directive (EU) 2019/790 on copyright and related rights in the Digital Single Market provides exceptions for text and data mining. Under the general exception, rights holders may expressly reserve their works in an appropriate manner, such as machine-readable means for content made publicly available online. Whether a given statement — including an AI-use policy in a registry record — is an effective reservation is a question for the competent courts, not for a registry.

07United Kingdom

The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 defines computer-generated works as works generated by computer in circumstances such that there is no human author. Under section 9(3), the author of a computer-generated literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work is taken to be the person by whom the arrangements necessary for its creation are undertaken. The provision predates generative AI; who undertakes those arrangements with current systems, and how the provision fits with the requirement of originality, are debated. Films are a separate category under the Act, so its application to the components of an AI-assisted production — script, images, music, the film itself — calls for specialist advice.

In December 2024 the government opened a consultation on copyright and artificial intelligence, which closed in early 2025. Alongside text and data mining and transparency, it asked whether the protection for computer-generated works in section 9(3) should be kept, and invited views on alternatives. This paper does not state an outcome; readers should check the current position before relying on section 9(3).

08China

In November 2023 the Beijing Internet Court decided Li v. Liu, concerning an image generated with a text-to-image model. The court found that the plaintiff’s intellectual input — designing and refining prompts, choosing parameters, selecting the result — was sufficient and that the image reflected the plaintiff’s personalised expression. It recognised the image as a protected work and held that the defendant’s unauthorised, unattributed use infringed the plaintiff’s rights.

This is a first-instance judgment of a specialised court, resting on the evidence of the plaintiff’s creative process in that case; it does not establish a general rule that AI-generated images are protected in China. Its lesson is evidential: the outcome depended on an account of what the plaintiff actually did, step by step. Copyright in China arises without registration; voluntary registration of works is available and can serve as preliminary evidence.

09Japan

In 2024 the Agency for Cultural Affairs published a General Understanding on AI and Copyright. It is guidance on the interpretation of the existing Copyright Act, not legislation; the courts have the final word. It explains that AI-generated material is not protected where it is produced without human creative intention and creative contribution, as when a user gives only a simple instruction, whereas a person who uses AI as a tool and makes a creative contribution can be the author of the result. The factors it discusses include the content and detail of instructions, repeated generation, selection among outputs, and later additions and modifications, each assessed case by case.

10Republic of Korea

In December 2023 the Korean government published a guide on generative AI and copyright. Under the guide, material generated by AI alone, without human creative contribution, is not protected and cannot be registered; registration is possible only for human creative contributions, such as the creative selection, arrangement or modification of material. Copyright in Korea arises without registration, which is voluntary; producers who register AI-assisted works there should identify the human contribution precisely.

11Thailand, Belgium, France and other jurisdictions

  • Thailand is a party to the Berne Convention. Copyright arises without registration, and national law is generally understood to presuppose a human author. Specific guidance on AI-generated works should be checked locally.
  • Belgium and France are EU Member States and Berne parties. The CJEU originality standard applies, protection arises without formality, and both traditions centre copyright on the natural person who creates the work, including through moral rights. National positions on AI-assisted works should be checked locally.
  • Elsewhere, three questions are a reliable starting point: does the law require a human author, how is originality assessed, and does registration have any legal effect? The answers should be confirmed with local counsel.

12What this means for evidence

If rights in AI audiovisual works depend on facts about the creative process, those who rely on the rights, and those who challenge them, need evidence of those facts — best assembled while the work is made, not later under pressure.

The facts that matter

  • Who: the people who made creative decisions, in which roles, under which agreements.
  • What: the creative decisions — script, design, direction, selection, arrangement, editing — and the elements generated by AI tools.
  • When: creation, each significant version, and first publication or screening.
  • With which tools: the AI systems and versions used, their terms of use, and the inputs supplied.
  • Under which licences and consents: pre-existing and licensed material, datasets, and the consents of performers and of anyone whose likeness or voice appears.

Why the form of evidence matters

Attributable
Each statement identifies who made it and on what basis, so that its reliability can be assessed and its author held to it.
Time-stamped
The time at which a statement or file existed can be established independently, not on the word of an interested party.
Versioned
Changes are recorded as new versions rather than overwriting earlier ones, so the history of a claim can be followed and later alterations detected.

Courts assess evidence under their own procedural rules and decide its weight; no private record binds them. Insurers underwriting errors and omissions risk need to see which rights are claimed and how they were cleared. Buyers and platforms need to know what they are licensing and whether AI use and likeness consents have been disclosed. A structured, attributable and time-stamped record lowers the cost of assessing a claim; it does not replace the assessment.

13How INDEX registration facts and verification scope fit

INDEX.FILM — International AI Audiovisual Asset Registry is operated by the Alliance on the registry–registrar model. Accredited registrars register works for rights holders and may verify facts within their accredited verification scopes; accredited partners, such as law firms and festivals, may act as issuers. INDEX records registration facts and verification scope, supporting the recognition of rights worldwide.

Declared and verified fields

Every field names its source: declared by the registrant, who is answerable for it, or verified by a named issuer, in which case the record lists the verifier, basis, date and items checked. A verified field that is later changed returns to declared. The VERIFIED scopes are rights holder identity, legal entity, registrant authority, file integrity and AI disclosure review.

AI disclosure

Every record carries an AI disclosure: a summary; whether imagery was generated; whether there are synthetic performers or a synthetic voice; real-person likeness, recorded as none, consented or unspecified; and the tools used. An optional AI-use policy states whether training, fine-tuning, style or character reference, and voice or likeness use are allowed, prohibited or negotiable. The disclosure remains a declaration unless reviewed within the AI disclosure review scope.

Fingerprints, versions and time-stamps

Content is referenced by SHA-256 fingerprints, optionally with an ISCC code (ISO 24138); the registry does not store or distribute films. Every version of a record is signed, hash-chained to the previous one and time-stamped under RFC 3161, so anyone can establish that a given file and set of statements were recorded at a given time, and that nothing has been changed silently since. Contracts, consents and verification materials enter the registry as hash references; originals remain with the issuing party.

From the BOUND level, a Certificate of Registration attests the registration facts and verification scope listed. Anyone can verify an INDEX ID, a certificate number or a SHA-256 fingerprint free of charge at index.film/verify.

CLEARED and Rights Clearance Schedules

At the CLEARED level, a Rights Clearance Schedule from reviewing counsel, an accredited law firm, is attached, stating territory, media, term, exclusions and conditions. It is that counsel’s attributed and verifiable opinion within its stated scope — not a decision of the registry, nor of a court.

Mapping the legal questions

QuestionWhat the record can showWhat remains for courts and counsel
Human creative contributionDeclared credits, AI disclosure and tools, as stated at a time-stamped momentWhether the contribution suffices for protection in a given country
Chain of titleThe declared rights holder; where VERIFIED, rights holder identity, legal entity and registrant authorityValidity of the underlying agreements; ownership as against third parties
Licensed inputsTools disclosed, the AI-use policy, hash references to licences held by the issuing partyWhether inputs were used lawfully; whether a reservation is effective
Likeness and performersReal-person likeness recorded as none, consented or unspecified; synthetic performers or voiceWhether a consent is valid and sufficient under the applicable law
ClearanceWhere CLEARED, the schedule’s territory, media, term, exclusions and conditionsAnything beyond the scope stated by counsel
Existence and integrityA file’s SHA-256 fingerprint and the time it was boundWho created the content, or who created it first

14What INDEX does not do

  • INDEX does not create, grant or transfer rights, and does not prove ownership or certify copyright. Whether a work is protected, and who owns it, is decided by courts and competent authorities.
  • INDEX does not assess originality or decide whether a human contribution suffices for protection in any country.
  • INDEX is not a public copyright office. A record carries no statutory presumption and does not replace national registration where that has legal effect, as in the United States.
  • INDEX does not verify declared fields. Only fields shown as verified have been checked, and only within the stated scope.
  • INDEX does not give legal advice. A Rights Clearance Schedule is the opinion of the counsel who issues it.
  • Recording an AI disclosure in INDEX does not by itself satisfy any statutory transparency or labelling obligation, such as those of the EU AI Act.
  • The INDEX Dispute Resolution Policy (“IDRP”) decides what the register should record, and with what flags, on the evidence presented. It does not determine copyright ownership with effect against third parties, does not award damages and does not prevent anyone from going to court. The registry implements final court decisions and arbitral awards.

15Practical recommendations

Document human creative decisions

  • Keep, as the work is made, the materials that show human authorship: scripts, storyboards, design references, prompt and parameter logs, selection records, edit decision lists and project files.
  • Record who made each significant creative decision, in which role, and reflect it accurately in the credits.
  • Where generated material is used, record how it was selected, arranged and modified, and keep the versions that show it.

Keep consents and licences

  • Keep the terms of service and licences of the AI tools and models used, in the version that applied at the time.
  • Keep licences for pre-existing and reference material, datasets, music and stock assets, and the agreements with every contributor in the chain of title.
  • Obtain specific written consents from performers and from anyone whose likeness or voice is reproduced or simulated, stating use, territory and term.

Register early

  • Register before festival submission, sales or distribution, and bind the master or screener fingerprint so that the record reaches BOUND and a Certificate of Registration is issued.
  • Make the AI disclosure complete and accurate from the start; record likeness as consented only where consent is held.
  • Where buyers, financiers or insurers require it, seek verification within the relevant VERIFIED scopes, or a Rights Clearance Schedule at CLEARED.
  • Where national registration has legal effect, as with the US Copyright Office, register there too, following its rules on disclosing and disclaiming AI-generated material.

Keep records current

  • Update the record when the work or its rights position changes — new cuts, a new rights holder, new licences or consents. Each update creates a new time-stamped version.
  • Correct errors promptly: materially false or misleading data, including on AI disclosure and likeness, can be challenged under the IDRP.
  • Review the position against current law in each country of exploitation, with qualified local counsel.

16Conclusion

The law has not settled every question that AI raises for audiovisual works, and will not settle them uniformly. The frame, however, is clear: in the jurisdictions reviewed, copyright follows human creative contribution; in Berne countries it arises without registration; and rights are decided by courts and competent authorities on the evidence before them. Within that frame, the advantage lies with those who can show, clearly and credibly, what was done, by whom, when, with which tools and under which permissions.

INDEX.FILM records registration facts and verification scope, separating declarations from verifications, attributing every statement and time-stamping every version, supporting the recognition of rights worldwide. It does not decide rights; it makes the facts on which they depend easier to find, check and trust.

17About this paper

Registration facts and the recognition of rights: AI audiovisual works across jurisdictions. White paper 3, Edition 1.0, published on 21 November 2026 by the International AI Audiovisual Asset Index Standards Alliance (“the Alliance”), operator of INDEX.FILM — International AI Audiovisual Asset Registry. The English edition is the reference edition.

This paper is for information only and is not legal advice. Law in this area is changing quickly. The jurisdiction overviews reflect publicly known developments up to mid-2026 and must be checked against current law before any reliance is placed on them.

Legislation, decisions and official guidance are cited by name and year from public sources. Their mention implies no endorsement of INDEX.FILM by, and no relationship between the Alliance and, the authorities concerned. Comments and corrections may be sent to registry@index.film.

Solicitudes

Únase a la red mundial de registro.

Hechos registrales y reconocimiento de derechos · INDEX.FILM